# SDD ledger — plan: .superpowers/sdd/surface-reflection/task-1-brief.md

| Check | Produces / consumes | Result |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Task 1 internal consistency | Test invariants drive the requested shader-only behavior | Clean: the requested broad reflection and separated reflection edge weight are independently testable. |
| Task 1 file interfaces | `mosaic.frag` consumes existing camera, light, gloss, pane and normal uniforms; no new pass is required | Clean: current plan requires no interface change outside the shader. |
| Task 1 preservation constraints | New final-pass reflection must not enter atlas/palette/history or change refraction sampling | Clean: explicit write scope and invariants cover the boundary. |

Environment: `D:\project\behind_glass` is not a Git repository, so native/manual worktree setup and SHA-based review packages are unavailable. Work proceeds in place with an exact pre-edit shader snapshot and file-based review package.

Task 1 implementer: `01a0c9b1-382a-79e1-9f89-93e834836c4a` (Luna). Status: DONE_WITH_CONCERNS; automated verification reported green, GPU/browser visual comparison delegated to controller.

Task 1: fix round 1/5 dispatched for two Important regression-test findings; production shader unchanged.

Task 1: fix round 1/5 result (1 addressed, 1 open — complete atlas-path exclusion not covered; production shader unchanged).
Task 1: fix round 2/5 dispatched for the remaining complete atlas-path exclusion finding; production shader unchanged.

Task 1: fix round 2/5 result (1 addressed, 0 open — complete effective atlas path compared with baseline; production shader unchanged).
Task 1: complete (file-based review clean; no Git commits because this workspace is not a repository).

Final whole-change Astra review: clean; no Critical, Important, or Minor findings. Ready to retain in the non-Git workspace.
Ruling: retain this plan's `.superpowers/sdd/surface-reflection` workspace — no Git history exists to preserve the task brief, fix-round record, or review packages elsewhere — cost if wrong: hidden workspace clutter remains in the project.